A recent legal decision increases the likelihood that successful plaintiffs will be able to recover punitive damages when asserting discrimination claims in New York City.
New York’s Court of Appeals has just clarified the legal standard applicable to punitive damages awards in NYC Human Rights Law (discrimination) cases, holding that the more plaintiff-friendly common law standard applies to such claims, rather than the more strenuous federal standard normally applicable to federal Title VII discrimination claims.
Under the common law standard, punitive damages are available where the defendant’s actions amount to willful or wanton negligence, or recklessness, or where there is a conscious disregard of others or conduct so reckless as to amount to such disregard.
Under the federal standard, punitive damages are available where there is intentional discrimination, with malice or with reckless indifference to the rights of an aggrieved individual.
This case, Chauca v Abraham, overturns precedent applying the Title VII standard to NYCHRL claims.
By Matthew L. Berman, Senior Associate
Read the case, Chauca vs. Abraham
Punitive Damages now more readily available in NYC Human Rights Law cases
Your Rights. Our Fight.
Contact Us Today To Schedule A Free Consultation
Valli Kane & Vagnini LLP - Press & News
NY Courts May Have to Redo Thousands of ForeclosureHearings Over Need for Appointed Counsel
By Brian Lee/ Law.com Thousands of foreclosure proceedings could potentially be headed for do-overs as a result of the court
Customer Service Reps Get Narrow Collective Cert. In OT Suit
By Abby Wargo/Law360 A Texas federal judge agreed Tuesday to certify a collective of customer service representatives alleging that a medical technologies corporation failed
Park co-naming expected for 2024
Lawsuit says Open Streets program for green space projects violates the ADA By Naeisha Rose/Queens Chronicle The grassroots effort to
5 Notable Workplace Bias Verdicts From 2023
By Anne Cullen/Law 360 Law360 (December 15, 2023, 6:32 PM EST) — A $36 million jury verdict that the U.S.
Marilyn Manson’s Former Assistant Wins Appeal to Revive a Previously Dismissed Sexual Assault Lawsuit
Ashley Walters claims Manson sexually assaulted her, whipped her and threw her against a wall when she was his assistant
Marilyn Manson’s Ex-Assistant Wins Appeal, Can Sue for ‘Horrific’ Sexual Harassment and Assault
By Nancy Dillon/ Rolling Stone “This is a great victory for all survivors as it provides a clear path for
Worker Settles Overtime Suit Against Home Remodeler
By Caleb Drickey/Law360 · 2023-10-16 19:49:04 -0400 · Listen to article A worker who accused a home remodeling firm of misclassifying him as an
Q&A: Attorney Sara Wyn Kane on Tough Sexual Assault Cases and New York’s Lookback Window
By Sara Hammel/The Landing As one of Delta Captain Andrea Ratfield’s attorneys, Sara Wyn Kane of Valli Kane & Vagnini LLP is familiar with
‘I don’t want to be in the darkness anymore’: Bronx case worker sues DSS over alleged sexual abuse, retaliation
By Aliyah Schneider/ Bronx Times Disclaimer: This story details various accusations of sexual abuse. A homelessness case worker on unpaid
NYC May Need To Rethink Property Transfer Program
By David Holtzman/ Law360 Law360 (September 13, 2023, 8:45 PM EDT) — A City of New York program that transfers